Queer Sounds / Queer Silence: Music is What Saves Our Lives
Track 1. Kampala: Rights, Agency, and Supralocal Solidarity
The rights to one's own body, identity, safety and intimacy are a global issue, and the rights of LGBTQIA+ people are the key part of it. These struggles for agency, just like all more or less brutal regimes that deny it, always manifest themselves locally, as well as within nation-states. Writing from Polish perspective, we are fully aware that homophobia, transphobia, etc., have become tools for the ideological mobilization of populist politicians and, as a result, have spread like filth among people (from criminal physical attacks to the declarations of so called "LGBT-free zones"). In this situation, we believe that our way of looking at cultural otherness in relation to the aforementioned rights to subjectivity and legal personality stems not from colonial paternalism, but from supralocal solidarity.
From this position, we listen to the voices describing the situation of non-heteronormative people living in or coming from the area between Kinshasa, Nairobi and Maputo. This is an extremely diverse territory, but in general, both the policies of the authorities and the attitudes of local communities can be described as discriminatory. To be able to present this multiplicity of experiences, we resorted to the cut-up method, combining excerpts from different countries and backgrounds, written by authors representing diverse perspectives – journalistic, philosophical and artistic. For this patchwork essay, we have cut up, shuffled and combined excerpts from Christopher Clark's article Gay, Out And On The Airwaves In Kinshasa1, the work Construction Sites: Exploring Queer Identity and Sexuality at the Intersections of Religion and Culture in Zambia by Zambian researcher Lilly Phiri2, Nelson Muparamoto's doctoral thesis Understanding Defiant Identities: An Ethnography of Gays and Lesbians in Harare, Zimbabwe3, Marlon B. Ross's essay Beyond the Closet as Raceless Paradigm4, Valerie Amani's text dedicated to the artist Arafa Cynthia Hamadi, and the works of these artists.
Guiding us among those voices will be Authentically Plastic, "electronic agitators" from Kampala. They agreed to answer some of our questions, particularly regarding the role of sound and music in creating safe spaces for non-heteronormative people in an African metropolis. Authentically Plastic operate as DJs, producers and artists in an openly political context, which led Ugandan conservatives to call them the "Demon of the Nile." Their main field of activity is the organization of ANTI-MASS open club spaces for experimental and queer artists. Authentically Plastic's performances combine, among others, gqom, vogue and techno. These styles form the basis into which rhythms from northern Uganda, early acid-house experiments and various inspirations from the category of Afrofuturism are mixed. Comparing the two increasingly repressive social environments in which we live, we asked about the role of sound in creating spaces that are welcoming to non-heteronormative people in Kampala, Nairobi and other African metropolises.
Track 2. Kinshasa: Airwave Resistance and Jeuniafrica
We begin the cut-up. The mixer flashes with a spectrum of rainbow colors. We slide the fader to channel two. Kinshasa.
In 2015, Izai, a self-employed IT technician, decided to start a weekly radio program that seeks to challenge the negative attitudes toward Kinshasa's LGBTI community. "The idea to start Jeuniafrica came from a strong need to talk, to be heard," says Izai, who came out at age 24. "Whenever LGBTI issues were being talked about, it was always in a pejorative manner, whether in the media, in politics or wherever else. I felt it was very important to try to provide a counter discourse."
"Jeuniafrica" was initially recorded on Izai's cellphone and uploaded to SoundCloud, with the first show going live on May 17, 2015. ("Jeuni" is a variation on the French word "jeune," which means young.) Jeuniafrica has cultivated a snappy conversational style interspersed with snippets of on-the-ground reporting, man-on-the-street quotes and in-studio interviews with church leaders, doctors, human rights workers, journalists and psychologists. Themes range from basic sexual health tips to dealing with depression to reconciling homosexuality and religion. A particularly popular episode asked Kinois, as Kinshasa residents self-identify, how they'd react to finding out a close family member was gay. All of the interviewees said they would disown their relatives.(…)
"Jeuniafrica can be a kind of substitute for that lost social structure," Izai says. According to an October report from a group of Congolese human rights organizations[^5], the combination of familial and workplace rejection pushes many LGBTI people onto the streets or into prostitution, where they risk becoming victims of violence or contracting HIV. LGBTI people across DRC are reluctant to seek out medical treatment or report cases of abuse for fear of prejudicial treatment, the report says.
Jeuniafrica confronts these issues head-on. Its team members pointedly cite sections of Congolese law pertaining to universal human rights and share details of LGBTI-friendly medical centers and health practitioners. Last year they aired a whole show on destigmatizing condoms, which are often demonized by DRC's conservative cultural mores. According to Bob Yala, director of Congolese nonprofit Secteur Media, radio is a particularly accessible medium for diffusing these kinds of messages in DRC (…).
"Oral accounts are ingrained in our culture. This means that radio is often enveloped in a kind of authority and so it can draw on that culture to educate and inform," says Yala, formerly a Radio France Internationale (RFI) journalist. Together with South Africa-based Children's Radio Foundation, Secteur Media helps train and equip the Jeuniafrica team. Children's Radio Foundation also covers the reporters' monthly stipend. Local radio can also empower marginalized people to speak out while retaining anonymity, Yala says. Rebecca, who goes by the pseudonym Seygou on air, says "Jeuniafrica is the only place where I can talk openly with people who have the same sexual orientation." In doing so, Rebecca believes she can "help other lesbians to open up about their sexuality.” (Clark)
Track 1. Kampala / Polyrhythms, Porosity, and Traditional Motifs
Crossfade to track 1. We hear the voice from Kampala again. We ask Authentically Plastic whether the relationship between so-called tradition and the experience of LGBTQIA+ people is unequivocally negative.
Track 3. Zambia: Traditional Feminine Spaces and Self-Construction
A new rhythm emerges, along with more voices. Chipobabz and Rihanna.
Through this song, Chipobabz forges his identities and sexualities along submissive ideologies encouraged of females in Zambian culture. Additionally, Chipobabz' response also shows how sexual performance is also regarded as pivotal in songs used by some participants to self-construct their identities and sexualities. Implicitly, Chipobabz reflects how through sexual gratification of his sexual partner, longevity of relationships is seemingly guaranteed. The question is: do participants who identify as male and assume masculine gender roles have the same levels of pressure as their female identifying partners to sexually perform and satisfy their partners so as to keep or sustain their relationships? The song that Chipobabz discussed encourages females in marriages to sexually gratify their husbands at all costs. Culturally, a wife is taught never to deny her husband sex. This raises questions on how fulfilling some gay relationships are when sex is used to ensure continuity of the relationship. This presents elements of homopatriarchy under which some participants forge their identities and sexualities (…).
Rihana in a similar manner as Chipobabz discussed the importance of sexual gratification of his partner as a measure for his femininity. Evidently, some feminine participants like Chipobabz and Rihana, upon assuming feminine gender roles, are also expected to perform sexual wonders to keep their men or risk losing them. Therefore, forging gay feminine identities entails performance as a feminine sexual being. The place of traditional counsellors in the self-construction of identities and sexualities of participants like Rihana is important as traditional teachings are passed on in feminine cultural spaces through songs, dances, drums, stories and demonstrations. Thus, by being a drummer in the feminine initiation rite of passage, Rihana can also be regarded as a traditional counsellor since drums and songs are modes of transmitting messages about married life. (Phiri)
Track 1. Kampala: Pre-Colonial Terms, Language, and Colonial Interruption
A gqom rhythm and an acid-house bassline kick in. Layered over this, with a completely different rhythmic pattern, along comes a type of drum we don’t know.
Track 4. Harare: Hate Speech, Pop Culture, and Street Resistance
We transition from Kampala to Harare. The beat drops out. A distorted, pseudo-machista voice sounds like a line being read mindlessly. In the other channel, a political speech hisses and stutters. When the old politician sought to rouse the crowds with his address, he never expected to sound like an idiot in this mix.
Evidently some of the names are derived from the president’s speeches whilst others come from popular international musicians who have anti-gay stunts. The president in one of his speeches influenced the anti-queer animus by describing gay men as 'breathing in other men’s necks', in this he was attempting to belittle gay people. The statement was meant to be an insult that they 'bend other men'. Buju Banton, Beenie Man, Elephant Man and Cello Culture are among some international reggae artists who have a significant following in Zimbabwe and their anti-gay chants (chichiman) are borrowed and used in the local context. Zimbabwe has been significantly impacted by dancehall music and it is popular in high density areas. The chichiman word is thus taken from dancehall songs which denounce gay men. Sindiso said, "Zvekunzi iwe chichiman, kune vaiti chichiman famba zvakanaka usaite semukadzi" [They shout at you chichiman walk properly don’t walk like a woman]. The growing genre of dancehall music in Zimbabwe, is heavily influenced by some of these international dancehall artists. The genre is popular among urban youths, some of their lyrics by artists such as Ricky Fire and Celsius Ghetto Life throw jibes at gay people. In this way the explicit hate music lyrics (homophobic chants) are apparently normalised, thus successfully branding gay people as abnormal. Some members of the society also use vernacular descriptions belittling gay men by depicting them as feminine and not real men. (Muparamoto)
Music is not neutral. The ways in which music is performed are not inconsequential. A sound rings out from the third channel. With an artificial reverb.
Track 5. Dar es Salaam & 3D Digital Spaces: Occupying Virtual Safe Havens
From a place that is everywhere to Dar es Salaam. No, this isn't Bongoland; it’s a three-dimensional digital space.
While I have explored this concept through physical spaces, recently I have been more fervently exploring the 3D digital landscape due to the Covid-19 lockdown in Kenya. Blender, SketchUp and Rhinoceros 3D have become almost empty stages for my queer body to occupy without fear of invalidation or, worse, expulsion. Using a 3D scanning application, I have been capturing solid digital forms of myself and others, and placing them into infinite landscapes in which they can exist and interact without any physical limitations.
Arafa C. Hamadi (they/them) is a non-binary, multidisciplinary artist working across diverse media and artistic disciplines in Tanzania and Kenya. While primarily active in the visual arts, Hamadi also creates poetry and engages in multi-, trans-, and intermedial artistic projects that not only possess an audiosphere but also extend directly into the realm of sound. The unifying thread of their work is the exploration of non-normative identities.
Trak 6. Safe Spaces
Rhythm and artificial space.
The rhythm resonates in the installation Spatial Sound Confessions6, created by Hamadi in collaboration with Shirin Khlif within the project Safe Spaces that also involves work Prefer not to Say created with Muozi.
The voice recites us the poem I, I7. This text served as the starting point for a recent sound-based video work.
I,
I am not a continued silence
that remains trapped within a clasped hand-held coin purse,
singing through my whistling throat as if drowning.
I,
I am not a ringing noise
screeching over the night, like a siren,
an unbolted screw yearning for deliverance, as if your hand alone
can hold me in place.
(...)
I do not need my hair cut or my arms stretched
or my chest engorged.
In the piece I read out a poem – I am interpreting an Arafa that existed then. The Arafa that existed then did not identify as non-binary, but had felt that they were at the cusp of understanding and somehow moving away from womanhood. Me reading the poem, I can relate to that person.
The Voice speaks further: "The conversation starts with me saying, I feel like we have no queer history, but then eventually we realize that it’s there! It’s there because we have the [Swahili] words for it. It’s there because there is this taboo that surrounds it. It’s there because my grandmother’s homophobia is specifically different from western homophobia. [It’s there] even in spiritual stories of the baobab and the ocean; maybe those are queer stories. I see myself in those stories and, thus, I claim them for myself."
Material Support and Queer Silence
Cut. Rhythm and noise remain. The voice of Authentically Plastic.
What kind of solidarity and assistance from local independent producers, listeners, and music industry professionals can support initiatives like yours? Or perhaps no support is needed at all?
Do you feel that reality allows you to speak, or does it silence you? Are we talking about queer sounds or queer silence?
Fade out.
Bio:
Authentically Plastic (UG) is an Artist, DJ, and producer based in Kampala, Uganda. Their genre-blending sets, which traverse both dark and bright moods, use styles such as Gqom, Vogue, and techno as foundations to explore other, more unconventional sounds. Their music draws inspiration from everything, from the quasi-electronic rhythms of northern Uganda to early noise/industrial experiments and live performances. Authentically Plastic is also the curator of an event called ANTI-MASS, which prioritizes female, queer, and experimental DJs/artists.
Glissando is a community of readers and writers, a circle of friends, and a democratic editorial collective comprising over a dozen members. It is the sum of countless conversations, meetings, and conflicts – a flurry of emails, Slack messages, and social media posts, alongside a dynamic fan page, an interactive website, and dozens of issues of a utopian print magazine. We seek a language to describe the contemporary experience of sound. Fascinated by a multitude of interpretive approaches, creative stances, genres, and artistic practices, we strive to foster an atmosphere of open exchange. While we value scholarly rigor and consistency, we place them on equal footing with the voices of newcomers, the boldness of manifestos, and formal experimentation. For us, the word "music" is a shorthand; we recognize the need to incorporate everything that manifests through sound into our discourse. The content we publish forms a kind of "encyclopedia of hearing," yet we aim to transform this accumulated knowledge into a tool for shaping the reality that surrounds us. We believe in enriching the ethos of music criticism with feminist, ecological, pro-social, and egalitarian values. Since 2004, "Glissando" has been in a state of constant evolution. Operating at odds with the market and frequently challenging dominant institutions, it brings together individuals from diverse backgrounds, working to build a network of connections within the local context of Central and Eastern Europe. Over all these years, the publication has drifted in various directions, yet the primary motivation behind its creation remains a passion for – and the pleasure of – engaging with sound.
* This patchwork essay is an English version of an article published in Glissando #40 / 2021.
___________________
-
Christopher Clark, "Gay, Out And On The Airwaves In Kinshasa," The Guardian, May 17, 2017. ↩
-
Lilly Phiri, Construction Sites: Exploring Queer Identity and Sexuality at the Intersections of Religion and Culture in Zambia (PhD diss., University of KwaZulu-Natal, 2021). ↩
-
Nelson Muparamoto, "Understanding Defiant Identities: An Ethnography of Gays and Lesbians in Harare, Zimbabwe" (PhD diss., University of Zimbabwe, 2017) and Nelson Muparamoto, interviews by Piotr Cichocki, March 20, 2014 and May 30, 2015. ↩
-
Marlon B. Ross, "Beyond the Closet as Raceless Paradigm," in Black Queer Studies: A Critical Anthology, ed. E. Patrick Johnson and Mae G. Henderson (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2005), 161–89. ↩
-
Congolese Human Rights Organizations, Joint Report on the Situation of LGBTI Persons in the Democratic Republic of Congo (Kinshasa, October 2015). ↩
-
Arafa C. Hamadi and Shirin Khlif, Spatial Sound Confessions, sound installation, Safe Spaces project. ↩
-
Arafa C. Hamadi, "I, I (a poem about reclaiming my body and my autonomy)," poem and sound-based video work. ↩